Fish penis. I’m at a braai when Leif, a friend, whispers the words “fish penis” in my ear. I look at him. “Ha!” he says, folding his arms. “Er, pardon?” I blink.
I’ve been insulted many times, but no one has ever called me a fish penis. What’s the right response to “fish penis”?
“It’s a crossword clue,” Leif says. “I just made it up. Solve it, Mr Crossword Guy.”
Fish penis. There are many ways to solve cryptic clues. You look for indicators that tell you the answer is an anagram that needs unscrambling or a charade that needs building or a homophone that needs hearing.
When there are just two words it’s usually a “double definition” clue. Double Ds are the building blocks of cryptic clues. The clue consists of two parts and the solution is a synonym of each. For example, the answer to Zero affection! (4) is LOVE. Love is both zero (think 40-love in tennis) and affection.
Potty train (4), compiled by cruciverbalist Paul (@crypticpaul), is one of the all-time greatest double definition clues. The clue makes you think of toddlers learning to use the toilet, but the answer is actually LOCO – a synonym for potty (as in crazy) and train (as in locomotive).
But back to Leif’s fish penis. I need to find a word that means both “fish” and “penis”.
I go through my fish synonyms: sole, pike, eel, carp, cod, salmon, trout, herring, tuna, clownfish, grunter, John Dory, ling, hake, piranha and tiger shovelnose catfish.
Nothing shouts “penis” at me. I try my penis thesaurus: willy, ding-a-ling, wiener, John Thomas, pecker and schlong.
Nothing shouts “fish” at me.
Leif goes to fetch firewood and I call Joni The Jam, my crossword chum, to see if she has any ideas. She notices that “John” is common in John Dory and John Thomas and sees a “ling” in ding-a-ling.
When Leif comes back I suggest John and ling. He shakes his head. “Gotcha,” he gloats. “The answer is a phrase that means utter contempt,” he says and hurries off to fetch fish to braai.
I call The Jam again. “It’s not a double definition clue,” I tell her. “This is what happens when non-setters compile clues. It’s like someone who has seen a few episodes of ER doing surgery. He’s treating me with contempt.”
Leif returns with the fish and plops it on the braai.
“What kind of fish is it?” I ask, trying to distract him from the fact that his clue has stumped me.
“It’s a snoek,” he grins. “Snoek, snoek, snoek,” he sings, putting his hand on his nose and waggling his spread out fingers at me.
Is he even allowed to cock a snook at me like that, I wonder. And that’s when the penny drops. If the clue were a patient needing surgery and if Leif were the surgeon, the clue would have died on the slab.
Although I’m a very amateur setter I try to resuscitate it: It sounds like a fish with a penis shows utter contempt (4, 1, 5).*
The clue wouldn’t make it into an actual crossword – not only because it’s clumsy, but because there’s an unwritten agreement among setters to avoid penises and F-words. Apparently rude words for body parts in the crossword world get up solvers’ noses. Just ask compiler Philistine, who produced this gem in last week’s Guardian puzzle: C-word upset many people (5).**
* COCK A SNOOK: a slang word for “penis” + A SNOOK, a homophone (“sounds like” is the indicator) of snoek (a type of fish).
** CROWD: an anagram of “c-word” (“upset” is the anagram indicator) gives a synonym for “many people”.
